Skip to content

A Bridge, Not a Barrier

These structural flaws create a snare net, trapping poor people in poverty, when our social welfare system needs to be a launchpad into opportunity and thriving. 

By Joshua Bandoch
|

Below is the oral testimony provided to the US Senate Special Committee on Aging for its hearing “A Bridge, Not a Barrier: Reforming the Safety Net to Reward Work.”

Introduction

Chairman Scott, Ranking Member Gillibrand, Senator Husted, and Members of the Senate Committee on Aging: Thank you for the opportunity to testify today, and for your commitment to making the American Dream a reality for our low-income neighbors by solving benefit cliffs. 

My name is Joshua Bandoch. I’m Senior Vice President of Policy Research at the Foundation for Research on Equal Opportunity, a 501c3 think tank dedicated to expanding opportunity for low-income Americans through freedom, innovation, and pluralism. We exist to truly empower everyone to unleash their potential, especially those least empowered to do so.

Unfair Choices

Marcella Patiño is a single mother of three who faced a gut-wrenching choice: should she strive to work hard, earn more, progress in her career, and achieve independence for her family, if doing so would make her family worse off because she’d lose too much assistance from government programs? Her answer: of course not. Benefit cliffs caused her to turn down work opportunities and raises.

Carlotta Jackson was faced with a similarly unfair choice, and rejected being “foolish” by “shooting” herself “in the foot.”  What was the harmful behavior Carlotta was avoiding? Marriage. Why?  Despite believing in the institution, marrying her long-time partner would have sent her over a benefit cliff. So she decided against it. 

Benefit Cliffs: Definition and Harm

A benefit cliff occurs when an increase in earnings—even as little as $0.48 per hour or $1,000 per year—can trigger an abrupt and disproportionate loss of hundreds or even thousands of dollars in federal benefits. These cliffs can be devastating. For example, in Illinois, a family can lose $25,000 in child care benefits when their household income goes from $54,000 to $55,000 in income.

Stated simply: benefit cliffs make it economically rational and psychologically understandable for poor people to reject opportunity, which harms them and their families. These structural flaws create a snare net, trapping poor people in poverty, when our social welfare system needs to be a launchpad into opportunity and thriving. 

The benefit cliffs phenomenon is widespread. Nearly one in four (22 percent) public assistance recipients reported taking at least one negative action to avoid losing benefits, including rejecting a job offer, declining a raise or promotion, or reducing their number of hours worked, according to research from the Center for Social Development at Washington University in St. Louis.

States’ Four Approaches

Red and blue states alike, ranging from Utah to Massachusetts, are eager to solve benefit cliffs. In a report published in October 2026, I detail the strategies nearly one-third of states have adopted or considered to address benefit cliffs. 

Their approaches generally fall into one of four categories: 

  1. Navigate cliffs with financial planning
  2. Expand benefits to mitigate cliffs
  3. Eliminate cliffs by guaranteeing income
  4. Jump the cliff through professional advancement

One commonality across these four approaches is that they do not directly solve or even truly mitigate benefit cliffs themselves, because they do not possess the authority to restructure federal welfare programs. Instead, they find ways to help individuals work around these cliffs, such as by navigating or jumping over them, or expand benefits in an effort to help them push through them. 

Federal Action is the Only Way to Comprehensively Eliminate Benefit Cliffs

That’s why federal action is necessary: it’s the only way to actually eliminate benefit cliffs. A comprehensive approach to solving benefit cliffs has three core elements:

  1. Restructure welfare programs to streamline benefits and eliminate benefit cliffs by adopting consistent tapers across programs. 
  2. Empower individuals through evidence-based workforce development, especially apprenticeships.
  3. Provide financial literacy training to help individuals acquire the financial knowledge necessary to manage their finances and build wealth.

Conclusion

Benefit cliffs are antithetical to the American Dream. If we don’t remove benefit cliffs, that Dream will increasingly turn into a mirage, then cease to exist, particularly for low-income Americans. 

That’s why the Upward Mobility Act is such important legislation. It empowers states, which are eager to act, to solve benefit cliffs. The appetite to act is there. States just need the authority. Once they have it, they can provide a blueprint for solving benefit cliffs across all fifty states and restore upward mobility and the American Dream itself for our low-income neighbors.

Thank you.

Photo of Joshua Bandoch

Joshua Bandoch

Josh is deeply passionate about fighting poverty and expanding opportunity for our low-income neighbors.