In September, the Trump administration celebrated the rebranding of the Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement (ICHRA). Initially enacted through regulation during the first Trump administration, ICHRAs allow employers to provide tax-free funds to employees to purchase their own coverage that is portable from job-to-job.
These plans, now called CHOICE (Custom Health Option and Individual Care Expense) Arrangements, have grown in popularity since their inception, albeit at a much slower pace than predicted. When federal regulations forming ICHRAs were finalized in 2019, federal agencies predicted that, once employers fully adjusted to the rules in 5 years, 800,000 employers would adopt ICHRAs. They further projected that more than 1 million people would be covered in 2020, growing to 11.4 million by 2029.
The reality is much more subdued. According to studies from the HRA Council, fewer than 4,000 employers offered Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs) in 2020, which include ICHRAs and its close cousin, the Qualified Small Employer Health Reimbursement Arrangement (QSEHRA). By the fifth year, just over 11,000 employers offered such arrangements.
The biggest impediment to CHOICE adoption is rooted in policy. First, workers are limited in the types of health plans they can buy with CHOICE employer contributions. Second, the plans workers most often buy through CHOICE—ACA plans on state and federal marketplaces—are too expensive because of onerous ACA regulations.
Americans sent a clear message to policymakers in the midterm election: focus on affordability. By expanding CHOICE-eligible plan offerings and deregulating the individual market, Congress and the president can seize the opportunity before the end of the year to strengthen CHOICE arrangements and, more broadly, affordable health insurance for millions of Americans.
CHOICE Enrollment is Growing. For now
Despite slow initial enrollment, Trump’s return to the White House coincided with an uptick in the pace of HRA enrollment. In 2025, more than 13,000 employers offered HRAs, growing to more than 20,000 in 2026—mostly due to increasing ICHRA enrollment. The growth in HRA adoption is a product of several factors, including rising employer costs and individual market competitiveness with the employer market. But the growth is also encouraging because it signals a movement toward personalized insurance where the employees and their dependents, i.e., patients, are in control of which coverage they obtain. Our research shows that the high cost and inefficiency of the American health care system is driven largely by the fact that individuals neither choose their own insurance, nor pay for it directly. In this way, HRAs are a step in the right direction.
The growth in CHOICE arrangements also represent workers’ best chance to obtain coverage that is truly portable from job-to-job. As more employers adopt these arrangements, a mid-year employment change would not only be seamless for a worker retaining the same plan features and provider networks, but he or she would also maintain the same progress toward meeting the plan’s deductibles and out-of-pocket costs, saving potentially thousands.
That said, rising premiums in the individual market could also hinder the growth of CHOICE Arrangements. As ACA plan costs continue to climb, employees may find that these arrangements leave them worse off financially than previous employer-based arrangements. For CHOICE arrangements to become a significant vehicle for expanding Americans’ health coverage options, further reforms are needed—particularly to make the individual-market plans employees are most likely to select through these arrangements more affordable.
Prior to the expiration of the enhanced Affordable Care Act (ACA) subsidies, we advocated for a temporary one or two year extension of those credits in exchange for permanent, premium-reducing deregulation of the ACA marketplace. Such reforms included returning to pre-ACA age rating to make ACA plans less expensive for younger individuals, and establishing reinsurance that directly funds the sickest enrollees and to reduce premiums for healthier individuals. In addition, Congress should directly fund cost sharing reductions available to low-income enrollees, rather than force insurers to roll such costs into the price of health plans—a reform that could save up to $50 billion in taxpayer dollars over 10 years and reduce silver plan premiums by 10-20 percent. Altogether, these reforms are designed to reduce plan premiums for the vast majority of health plan enrollees, especially workers and their families in CHOICE Arrangements.
Another problem facing potential CHOICE enrollees are restrictions on the types of plans they can buy. Under a CHOICE Arrangement, consumers may only purchase ACA-compliant health plans. This means individuals cannot choose other affordable insurance products that may be a better fit, like short-term health plans, health sharing ministries, or even a spouse’s employer group plan.
Reform Could Not Come at a Better Time
Without reform, no matter how attractive the CHOICE concept might be, adoption will always be hampered by prohibitions on using CHOICE to buy certain types of plans and the ever-increasing costs of individual market plans. But these restrictions and cost inflation are not inevitable—they are the result of poorly designed laws and regulations that can be repealed.
Congress and the president can show they hear the electorate loud and clear, by enacting serious reform that pairs the flexibility of CHOICE with market reforms to make insurance more affordable. These reforms include:
- repealing restrictions on using CHOICE arrangements to purchase alternative insurance plans, such as short-term plans and health sharing ministries,
- returning to pre-ACA age rating to reduce plan costs for younger enrollees,
- establishing reinsurance in the ACA market, pooling the riskiest enrollees to reduce plan cost for healthier enrollees, and
- directly funding cost-sharing reductions to reduce plan premiums across the ACA market.
With these reforms, the United States will supercharge the adoption of CHOICE Arrangements and move the nation toward a health care system where patients are in control of their coverage and their health care dollars—and ultimately, deliver a more affordable health care system.